Sunverge and Stem, two California-based behind-the-meter battery startups, have landed their first international projects in Japan, joining mutual investor Mitsui in a series of virtual power plant projects for massive utility Tokyo Electric Power Co.
The projects, announced Monday, are relatively small-scale, considering Tepco's scale as Japan’s biggest utility. Stem’s Tepco project will involve three commercial-industrial building sites with about 750 kilowatt-hours of battery capacity, one of which, a recycling center in the Tokyo suburb of Yoshikawa, started operations two weeks ago, Stem CEO John Carrington said in a Tuesday interview.
Sunverge CEO Martin Milani declined to give details on the scale of its work with Tepco in a Monday interview. But he did say that several of the company’s “dozens” of 19.6 kilowatt-hour battery-inverter units have been deployed in C&I locations owned for about a year, based on work with Mitsui that started in early 2016.
Still, the two projects mark the first announced international projects for Stem, and an important new market for Sunverge, which is also operating in Australia. And with Tepco facing a future that’s much less reliant on nuclear power, and much more renewable and distributed in nature, with more competition for big energy customers, both companies are hoping these small-scale experiments will be the start of something much bigger.
“We think it’s the beginning of a variety of opportunities out there,” Carrington said. “We’ve talked about getting into new markets for some time,” he said, adding, “This will be a very compelling market. It will be evolving over the next 12 to 24 months.”
Japan’s energy sector has been evolving, and struggling, since the 2011 Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant disaster and the subsequent closure of much of the country’s nuclear reactor fleet, which caused major energy shortages and forced the country into emergency efficiency measures.
Since then, the situation has stabilized, thanks largely to cheap imported natural gas, and several reactors have since reopened under pressure from the country’s largest utilities. Still, public opinion remains opposed to nuclear power, which makes up only about 2 percent of the country’s energy supply, compared to 30 percent before Fukushima.
Meanwhile, Japan is still adding renewables at a rapid pace, despite the government’s scaling back its renewables goals and slower-than-expected growth and cutbacks from its wind and solar feed-in tariff program.
Finally, Japan is undergoing a reform of its energy regulations, meant to open the vertically integrated system to more competition among energy providers. These combined factors are pushing the country’s biggest utilities to invest in distributed energy technologies, including batteries.
Mitsui, which has invested in Stem and Sunverge alongside a range of renewable and distributed energy companies, will be the lead on the two projects. That makes it the owner and financier of Stem’s battery systems in this case, Carrington said.
But Stem will operate the lithium-ion battery units, individually and in aggregate, from the same software platform, dubbed Athena, that runs its fleets in California, New York and Hawaii. “Our platform can aggregate that network -- now small, but we expect it will grow -- and provide a flexible demand resource for the utility, particularly as they add more renewables on the grid,” he said.
Sunverge CEO Milani said the company is being asked to test three use cases. The first is fairly straightforward -- dispatching or importing power from the batteries to prove they’re tightly controlled enough to maintain a target wattage reading at each site. (Milani will speak today on a panel at Greentech Media’s Energy Storage Summit 2017 conference in San Francisco.)
The second is to reduce demand charges, or extra costs imposed on buildings that exceed certain limits on how much power they can draw from the grid at any one point in time. That’s the core value proposition for most of the systems deployed by Stem, Green Charge Networks and other behind-the-meter battery players in the C&I space.
While this business case is limited to markets like California or New York where demand charges are high enough to justify the cost, that’s certainly the case in Japan, where demand charges can add up to more than $10 per kilowatt, compared to an average electricity price of 30 cents per kilowatt-hour, he noted.
The third use case is where the virtual power plant controls come in, Milani said. Many of its deployments in Tokyo are owned by the same company, he noted, and that company wants to “maintain them as a logical node -- a nanogrid if you will -- so if the total aggregate is supposed to have a load of x, and a certain site cannot meet its goals, we can use available capacity from a sister site and level them off.”
In that way, “We can balance the load and reduce bills, even if one site is overcharging,” both from an electrical and a financial perspective, he said. “It’s basically treating an organization as a single organization, no matter how many sites it has. For Tepco, it could involve a specific contract with a specific tariff for a customer with multiple sites, that says, ‘Hey, if I want to ask you to reduce something, you can figure out which sites to reduce from, and as long as I get that capacity, I’m happy.’”
Stem’s Tepco deployment is also based around demand-charge reduction, Carrington said. “The prosumers in Japan are ready for that,” he said, noting the rapid increase in demand response -- technology to reduce power use in response to grid needs or price signals -- in the country since Fukushima. “It’s pretty well known that they’re very energy-conscious, and that’s had an impact."
But Stem is also testing some as-yet unspecified virtual power plant capabilities with Mitsui and Tepco, he said. “It allows them to leverage the real-time balancing and intelligence offered by our system and our software.”
Both companies said that the data they’re collecting from the sites as they run through their VPP paces will be examined by Mitsui, Tepco and Japan’s Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry, or METI, as part of the project. METI designated a total of 7 billion yen ($59.4 million) in subsidies for VPP development in fiscal years 2016 to 2017, Sunverge noted.
Tepco is in the midst of a massive smart meter deployment, and been investing in renewable energy both at home and abroad. It’s also investing in startups on the grid edge, such as its £500,000 equity investment in Moixa Energy, and its €3 million ($3.5 million) investment in blockchain-based peer-to-peer energy trading startup Conjoule.