• Friday, November 20, 2009 Latest Update: 4:41PM
Michael Kanellos | October 17, 2008 at 4:00 AM 2 Comments

The Saudi Arabia of ‘Your Name Here’

If you aren’t the Saudi Arabia of something, you’re just not cutting it. Here’s a list of some of the claims for Saudi Arabia-hood from the alternative energy world.

The Saudi Arabia of Tidal Power: The Pentland Firth, separating Scotland from the Orkney Islands. It could provide up to 25 percent of Europe’s tidal power. But don’t include wave power in that. Both Scotland and Ireland claim to be the Saudi Arabia of wave.

The Saudi Arabia of Wind: The Great Plains states. Three of them—North Dakota, Kansas and Texas—could provide the bulk of the electrical needs of the U.S., claim advocates. North Dakota also holds claim to being the Saudi Arabia of compressed air storage.

The Saudi Arabia of Uranium: A tie! it’s either Western Australia or Cameco, a corporation with uranium holdings in Canada.

The Saudi Arabia of Algae: Western Australia again. you wouldn’t think there would be a huge contest on this, but an entrepreneur recently tried to convince me that the salty water, open desert and plentiful sun will make the lands beyond Perth the Saudi of scum.

The Saudi Arabia of Coal: The U.S. of course, followed by the other big land mass countries. The U.S. has the most, with 268 billion tons, followed by Russia (173 billion tons), China (126 billion tons) and India (102 billion tons). The four collectively hold 67 percent of the recoverable reserves.

The Saudi Arabia of Geothermal: Nevada. In turn, this make Reno the biggest little Riyadh in the world.

The Saudi Arabia of Solar Thermal: Australia for a third time. You can already hear presidential candidates denying that they’ve ever been to an Outback Steak House.

The Saudi Arabia of Hydrogen: The Columbia River in Oregon. And if you are in the mood, you can visit the state institution where they filmed “One Flew over the Cuckoo’s Nest.”

The Saudi Arabia of Biomass: Georgia. “That’s right. Home not only to peanuts, corn, pecans and cotton, but also pine trees and poultry farms,” say advocates.

Comments [2]

  • Pradeep 10/17/08 7:56 AM

    I dont mean to be picky, but I think some of the comparisons are too broad. The following is just one example, and it does not mean that I do not support this specific form of renewable energy.
    Take the case of hydroelectric-H2-ammonia example:
    In a single second, the spring flow of the Columbia River can produce 250,000 cubic feet of water. The hydrogen locked in each cubic foot of water equals 3.64 gallons of gasoline.
    Saudi Arabia’s entire remaining oil reserves equal about 260 billion barrels — 5.2 trillion gallons of gasoline. The Columbia produces hydrogen equal to the 5.2 trillion gallons of gasoline, all of Saudi Arabia’s remaining reserves, in 67 days. It does this year in and year out for the rest of time.

    Comparing the discharge of the Columbia river to the amount of actual energy stored in oil reservoirs is meaningless. If discharge is the only criteria, the Amazon and the Nile should come ahead of the Columbia. One more reason why the discharge data are useless is that it does not indicate the potential to do useful work with this volumetric flow rate of water. Unless we have new hydroelectric power plants, or go the mini-hydel route, this water flow will not do any useful work. The third reason why this comparison is misleading is that the efficiency of electrolyzing water to produce hydrogen is somewhat low. To do a real comparison, one has to figure out all the steps involved in producing hydrogen or ammonia, starting from the available hydroelectric capacity. The article does not mention any numbers as to the amount of hydrogen that can be produced, the costs etc.

    Reply
  • greensolutions 10/20/08 10:21 AM

    I’d add the N. American great plains—the Saudi Arabia of biochar/syngas.  If only they’d stop practicing the agricultural equivalent of “drill, baby, drill”, we could take advantage of this carbon negative, water saving, fertilizer-free, localized energy resource while rebuilding our abused soils.

    Reply

Green Light

Greentech Media's Green Light blog covers the full-scope of the greentech world, while expanding the range of our daily news reporting with brief and insightful blog posts from our Greentech Media editors, GTM Research analysts and numerous guest bloggers.

.