GreenFuel Technologies Closing Down

The Harvard-MIT algae company winds down after spending millions and experiencing delays, technical difficulties.

GreenFuel Technologies, one of the earliest, best funded and most publicized algae companies, is shutting its doors, a victim of the credit crunch.

"We are closing doors. We are a victim of the economy," said Duncan McIntyre at Polaris Venture Partners, which invested in Greenfuel.

Although it has raised millions of dollars and landed a high-profile deal with Auranta in Spain to erect test facilities, it could not get money to complete the project. In January, it laid off 19 people, or half of the staff.

The company has also been chronically saddled with delays and technical problems. The company's plan was to pump carbon dioxide from smokestacks into bioreactors – i.e., sealed plastic bags filled with algae and water. The algae would grow fat on the carbon dioxide and later be harvested by GreenFuel to be turned into oil for biodiesel. Protein and other matter from the algae would also be sold to pet food manufacturers.

Ideally, GreenFuel's plants would sequester greenhouse gases, help the U.S. get off foreign oil, and bring the company revenue from carbon credits and product sales.

Getting the whole thing to run smoothly, though, was tougher than expected. GreenFuel could grow algae. The problem was controlling it. In 2007, a project to grow algae in an Arizona greenhouse went awry when the algae grew faster than they could be harvested and died off. The company also found its system would cost more than twice its target.

That led to the company laying off about half its staff of 50 at the time and hiring Ethernet inventor Bob Metcalfe as interim CEO. Metcalfe led the restarting and decommissioning of the Arizona project after what he said was a successful trial, and helped the company raise $13.9 million in funding from VCs including Access Private Equity, Draper Fisher Jurvetson and Polaris Venture Partners.

In July, shortly after Metcalfe said GreenFuel was seeking a series C round of funding and was looking into two projects in the United States (see GreenFuel Closes In on Series C), GreenFuel named former Dow Chemical executive Upfill-Brown as its new CEO. Since then, GreenFuel hasn't announced any more funding or any U.S. projects.


Join industry leaders and influencers at Greentech Media's Enterprise Carbon Accounting event.

8 Comments

  • Contract Employee 05/13/09 5:14 PM

    I’m surprised it took the VCs this long to realize GF was a mess and a waste of cash.  Someone will be successful with algae-to-biofuel, but it’s been obvious for quite some time it wouldn’t be those clowns.

    Reply
  • Frank Smith 05/13/09 8:51 PM

    I wondered what would happen to Greenfuel after it had an algae glut. If they couldn’t control their harvest, how could they control anything else?

    Reply
  • Bri 05/14/09 6:29 PM

    Wow, 50 people to engineer and market a bunch of damn tubes??? This sounds like a glut of money, combined with management who, surprise, didn’t understand the first thing about algae, destroyed the company.

    Reply
      • Ricky-Pooh 05/17/09 2:06 PM

        Why are VC’s so stupid?  My Company could cover 75 square miles with the 100 million… And we have developed a patented technology that increases the amount of oil produced by 355%.

  • Jonesy 05/15/09 5:20 PM

    Competent management was brought in much too late to do any good in a credit-less economy.  Too bad, as this was very exciting stuff (and NOT tubes/bags).

    Reply
  • GreenArt2LifeBiz 12/29/09 12:38 PM

    I’m sorry that GF got caught up in the big finance bubble mentality.  The cart does not go before the horse, as the saying goes.  Some Europeans tried to build a 2 MW wind turbine in the mid-80s.  The useful turbines were in kWs until the 90s, and now, 20 to 30 years later they are up to 6 or 7 MW which work. 
      Still it goes deeper.  VC’s are as dumb as “profit-maximization” is deluded and sociopathological.  They are merchant aristocrats who treat human beings like their serfs and robots.  William Greider has covered the basic issues well in his The Soul of Capitalism, among others.

    Reply
  • GreenArt2LifeBiz 12/29/09 1:11 PM

    One point is worth adding, I’d say, that additional wisdom does not fail in these matters.  First things first, and baby steps.  I’ve personally got roots in the Harvard-MIT axis, and have noticed that they operate in the stratosphere.  Real sustainable projects are grassroots oriented, like Mohammed Yunus’ Grameen Bank, and all kinds of microfinance.  Heck, even Whole Foods started as two small health food stores.

    Reply
  • andre 02/6/10 1:57 PM

    Build an algae pond and they will come? VCs I mean, to sip profits from nature…

    Reply
.