The recent $55 million raise at MiaSolé was not an equity raise but rather convertible debt, according to sources close to the firm. That debt will convert into Series G equity when and if there is a “qualified financing” of Series G stock.
This takes nothing away from the technical progress being made by MiaSolé in the performance of its CIGS panels. It does frame CEO John Carrington's words as a bit more "nuanced" with regards to his response on valuation.
Our source has informed us that the convertible money gets a 20 percent discount to the Series G price, which could be above or below Series F. If Series G is at the same price per share as Series F ($4.33) then the notes would convert at $3.464 per share. There is also interest accruing on the notes and warrant coverage with even more warrant coverage if MiaSolé doesn't close the qualified financing in a certain period of time. The deal was attractive enough for virtually every preferred shareholder to participate, according to our source.
The convertible notes mature in one year, but MiaSolé will need to raise more funding or sell the company before a year is up, as the recent cash infusion won’t last 12 months.
The bottom line is that MiaSolé and its CEO remain in an urgent and tight situation, not unlike any solar startup in today's market. The firm's modest volumes and high manufacturing costs and presumably negative margins mean that volumes will have to rise to demonstrate a positive margin contribution. And that's going to take higher burn and more funding.
An IPO for a non-profitable CIGS solar firm does not appear to be in the cards in the current market. That makes MiaSolé's optimum path an acquisition, a plan that Carrington suggested almost as soon as he assumed the CEO post in December of last year.
MiaSolé could be attractive to a deep-pocketed corporation that views the crystalline silicon race as having been largely conceded to the Chinese with CIGS as the next frontier with no established long-term leader. MiaSolé’s efficiency advantage and relatively low capex might make the company attractive.
The original article on the $55 million raise follows.
These are challenging times to be raising VC funding for a solar company. And it's probably even more difficult if there is a CIGS thin-film stack involved.
But, in a bit of positive news, MiaSolé, a manufacturer of copper indium gallium selenide (CIGS) thin-film photovoltaic solar panels, just announced that the firm has won $55 million in new funding, mostly from existing investors.
I spoke with MiaSolé's new CEO, John Carrington.
Carrington said the original raise was intended to be $40 million but was eventually "oversubscribed" at $55 million. The funding "primarily came from insiders," according to the CEO.
Existing investors include Voyageur Mutual Funds, Kleiner Perkins, Firelake Capital, and VantagePoint Venture Partners, et al. Board members include KP's John Doerr, Firelake's Marty Lagod, VantagePoint's Stephan Dolezalek, and Rob Chandra of Bessemer. The firm has raised in the neighborhood of $550 million in VC funding since its founding in 2004.
Unlike, say, Nanosolar, which took a ruthless hit on valuation in its recent $20 million raise, Carrington said that MiaSolé's valuation was not changed in this round. MiaSolé raised most of a $125 million round F in February of last year at a pre-money valuation of $550 million.
The points Carrington continues to hit on are that MiaSolé is executing on its efficiency goals with 14 percent efficient panels in production now and 15 percent achievable in production by the end of the year. The funding is to keep improving and executing on the efficiency roadmap.
The other point that Carrington stresses is that the firm's capex is $0.50 per watt, which betters that of leading cadmium telluride thin-film panel maker First Solar, as well as the crystalline silicon vendors.
Obviously, $55 million doesn't allow for capacity expansion from the firm's current 150 megawatts, but first that current capacity has to be sold and shipped. MiaSolé has deployed over 55 megawatts of solar modules to-date.
In MiaSolé's favor is a remarkable trajectory of efficiency improvement. Panel efficiency has grown by more than 30 percent from 2011 to 2012. The CEO said that the firm was also working on a flexible rolled rooftop solar product and that the gap in market success (see ECD) in flexible solar was the low efficiency values offered until now.
We published a technical presentation from the firm earlier this week.