Update: California Energy Storage Bill AB 2514 Signed Into Law by Governor

“Utility-scale energy storage is one of the game-changers,”  according to veteran investor and energy thought leader Gunderson.

Update: September 29, 5:30pm PT

California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger just signed AB 2514, an energy storage bill, into law. This is promising news -- but don't expect batteries and flywheels in every backyard and solar farm just yet. 

What happens next? The California Public Utility Commission (CPUC) is to "open a proceeding to determine appropriate targets, if any, for each load-serving entity to procure viable and cost-effective energy storage systems."   

I recently spoke to a CPUC representative who suggested that that storage target could be zero if the CPUC decides it should not set a mandate.

Stay tuned.  And if you are a proponent of utility-scale energy storage or a particular storage technology, you might want to keep an eye on the CPUC's activiities and speak up at CPUC hearings.  Greentech Media will certainly be monitoring and reporting on the action in this legislative and policy effort.

***

Update August 27: AB 2514 was just voted out of the Assembly (concurrence with Senate amendments) 44 ayes -25 noes.  Next (and final) step: The Governor's Office. The last day for the Governor to sign any new legislation into law is September 30, 2010.

***

Utility-scale energy storage is a game-changer but it can't happen without the proper regulatory environment. 

A step in that direction was taken today.  California's AB 2514, a bill mandating utility-scale energy storage, made it through the California Senate (22 ayes to 12 nays). 

Next, the bill returns to the Assembly for concurrence in Senate amendments (the Assembly must agree/disagree with amendments made to the bill while it was heard in the Senate).  If successful in concurrence, then the bill goes before the Governor.  The Governor must sign the bill into law by September 30 of this year.



The Senate floor analysis is here.

Here's a brief excerpt from the bill:

This bill would require the CPUC, by March 1, 2012, to open a proceeding to determine appropriate targets, if any, for each load-serving entity to procure viable and cost-effective energy storage systems and, by October 1, 2013, to adopt an energy storage system procurement target, if determined to be appropriate, to be achieved by each load-serving entity by December 31, 2015, and a 2nd target to be achieved by December 31, 2020.

And here's a comment, just received by email from Edward G. Cazalet, Ph.D., Vice President and Co-Founder of Megawatt Storage Farms:

The passage of this bill is a major step forward for reliable, clean and lower cost electric power for all Californians. Electricity storage will enable more clean, local renewable wind and solar power supported by clean storage. With storage, Californians will have clean power when and where they need it and with less need for new transmission lines.

 

I urge the signing of this bill by Governor Schwarzenegger and timely implementation by the California Public Utilities Commission.  More than a year ago I first advocated such legislation. Based on my analysis, California will require about 4,000 megawatts of clean, fast storage mainly from grid scale batteries located close to loads on the distribution grid with the capability to store several hours of energy.

***

Maurice Gunderson, senior partner at CMEA Capital, believes that grid-scale storage is a "game-changer" in the alternative energy battle.  Gunderson has been working in the energy industry for more than 30 years and co-founded the first greentech investing firm, nth Power.

CMEA Capital’s portfolio companies include A123 (lithium-ion batteries), Contour Energy (advanced battery technologies), Solaria (solar panels) and Codexis (biofuels).

We spoke to Mr. Gunderson about technology, policy and the investment landscape for energy storage.

Greentech Media is no stranger to this topic; we understand its importance in renewable energy and have covered it extensively.  Here are some recent storage-related articles:

 

"Large-scale energy storage can turn renewables into dispatchables"

Gunderson believes that grid-scale storage is the next frontier in renewable energy investments.  CMEA does not yet have an investment in this sector, but Gunderson says, "we are looking at three of them now."  Expect to see an announcement in the coming months.

Gunderson continues, "At CMEA, we're looking at novel chemistries -- they won't be lithium-ion or sodium-sulfur (NaS) and they will be suitable for utility applications."

"The holy grail is very large-scale batteries, but they have to work at grid lifetimes and duty cycles."  Unfortunately, at present, "There are no batteries that last decades."

As for flow batteries, Gunderson said that there are fuzzy distinctions separating fuel cells, flow batteries and batteries.  There is plenty of research on various materials for flow batteries. People get them to work, they look promising, but after a few years they get a show-stopper problem. That issue eventually gets solved, but then new problems arise.  "We've never gotten to the point where they're reliable enough for utility use,"  he said, adding, "There are a lot of people working on this and I think we're going to get there in the 5-to-10-year time frame."

"I've been looking for this for thirty years"

Gunderson continues, "There are lots of folks working on energy storage ideas, but most of them are half-baked. Most storage on the market is not really market-ready -- the economics are unknown. It causes increased costs and uncertainties."

He adds, "If I were a wind power developer and had a reliable battery that I could install behind the fence, it might double the price, but I can sell the power when people want it and triple my revenue by selling at peak."

We already have as much wind as we can use in California, yet all of the capital budget is going towards wind and solar and "we can't use it."  He adds, "Interestingly, in California, we have a very high quality Public Utility Commission and Energy Commission, but they often are not listened to."

Other Storage Technologies

Gunderson cited other energy storage schemes: ice storage, for instance.  Ice is cheap, it works, and there are no environmental hazards.  "Imagine a convention center: you make the ice at night and melt it for cooling during the day."  A convention center that has little activity at night would be a good fit for this type of solution versus a building like a hospital that has energy loads both day and night.

Sodium sulfur (NaS) is "a bit of a headache because of high temperature and could be replaced by new battery concepts."

As for compressed air energy storage (CAES) and pumped hydro, Gunderson had this to say: "If nature gives you a canyon, you should use it [for pumped hydro]. If you happen to have that, you're lucky: you can put in as much wind as you can finance.  When the wind blows, you pump the water uphill."  Unfortunately, the ability to do that varies widely, and in California, "we're taking down dams not putting them up."

Energy storage is a "baby industry" according to Gunderson, and there are a number of potential business models, such as Megawatt Storage Farms' Independent Storage Provider concept, as well as "inside the fence" applications.

Gunderson is an optimist, a necessary quality for a venture investor.  He concluded, "We can go to Mars, we can go the the Moon, we can do this.  All we have to do is focus."

Energy Storage Policy

In late July, the U.S. Senate introduced new legislation, known as the Storage 2010 Act, that will provide up to $1.5 billion in tax credits to storage energy projects connected to the U.S. electric grid. The initiative is intended to support intermittent energy sources, including wind and solar power, which can moderate demands during peak hours and facilitate a “smart grid,” using the power when it’s actually needed.  This might provide a boost for the energy storage industry, broadening the potential for better returns and increased investments in this area.

AB 2514 is a bill currently in the California legislative process that has been, in part, suggested by Ed Cazalet of Megawatt Storage Farms and recently championed by California gubernatorial candidate Jerry Brown. It has gone through some changes as it has made its way through the legislative sausage maker but nevertheless, the measure remains a mandate for energy storage.  

Differing Viewpoints on Storage

 

Amory Lovins of the Rocky Mountain Institute challenges the concept of baseload power and the roles that renewables can play.

We have a commenter on Greentech Media's comment boards who, when I write about storage and dispatchability, seldom fails to to inform me of the following: "Large-scale energy storage co-located with VERs [Variable Energy Resources] is unlikely ever to be commonplace.  It is irrational and based on a fundamental misunderstanding of variability and grid integration.  For a good summary, I recommend this recent report out of NREL (this means you, Eric Wesoff):



Here's the URL for the NREL PDF:  http://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy10osti/47187.pdf

Here are a few excerpts from the cited report's conclusions that the commenter might have in mind.  The report's conclusions don't seem to match the commenter's vehemence:

The report doesn't say that storage is unlikely; rather, it is complicated and has to be carefully assessed, economically, technologically and from a regulatory standpoint.  On that we agree.

Despite objections from our commenter, utilities and power providers are incorporating storage into the grid.  Note that Tres Amigas chose Xtreme Power to furnish energy storage and power management at the Tres Amigas SuperStation, a PE-backed transmission facility linking the Eastern, Western and Texas Interconnections.  The storage is being implemented, in part, to integrate variable generation.

***

We welcome you to weigh in on the importance of energy storage in the smart grid and to attaining a high penetration of renewables.