Trader Vic’s in Palo Alto, Calif., a significant producer of porcine animal fat, was the obvious choice of venue for
The VC Taskforce and the hosting of a recent panel on Next-Generation biofuels. Next-Generation biofuels, depending on who’s doing the defining, includes cellulosic ethanol, synthetic genomics for bug manipulation, algae fuels and the like. These sectors have received billions in VC and PE funding in preparation for the emergence of this zero billion dollar market.Â

Here are some quotes from the event:
“This business is about energy density," said Michael Burnside, President and CEO of
Catchlight Energy, a very large joint venture between Chevron and Weyerhauser, adding that: "But 50 to 100 miles is the maximum you can transport bio-feedstocks and still be viable," and “Biofuels remain capital intensive at $5 to $7 per annual gallon versus ~$1.25 per annual gallon for petro-fuel refineries.�
Neal Gutterson, President and CEO of
Mendel Biotechnology, a man with 26 years in the ag-biotech industry had this to say:

“Corn has been beaten up in the last few years, perhaps deservedly. We need to minimize the impact in biodiversity.�
Mendel is a 12-year-old firm, involved in the sequencing of the first plant genome. “We see
Miscanthus as the best perennial crop, Sorghum as the best annual crop. Think about the sheer acreage -- we need hundreds of millions of acres globally to meet our transportation needs. Our primary partner is BP and their goal is to have a global presence in biofuels,� Gutterson said.
“The great thing about perennials, they minimize inputs like pesticides and nutrient requirements,� he said.
“The role for small startups is a challenge. How does a startup work with BP or Chevron? The large chemical, fuel and chemical companies must be involved,� Gutterson said.
Jim Mullen, Partn

er at
Morrison & Foerster, is a patent attorney in biotech. Here’s his take with regards to the state of the art in algae: “A dose of reality is important. While there is algae cultivation for nutritional and pharmaceuticals -- algae as a source for commercial fuel is still five to 10 years away,� he said, adding that: “You willl not be putting algae products into your gas tank anytime soon. A lot of R&D -- more 'R' than 'D' -- has to be done.�
Jim Embler, CEO of ZeaChem and recovering engineer testified to the value of bio-feedstocks said: “A few years ago McDonalds paid you to remove their food waste, recently companies are paying McDonalds for their waste, and a few weeks ago -- there was news that organized crime is now stealing the grease.�
“Third-generation biofuels have to be non-food,� Embler also said.
At the conclusion of the panel, we lit tiki torches, I played Don Ho tunes on the ukelele, and we drank rum drinks from hollow pineapples.