It's always fun to see how the mainstream journalists over-react to the latest short-term numbers, and how their editors feel compelled to over-dramatize every headline. Thus last week we saw an article in the NYT with the headline "Clean Tech's Future Dims as Financing Drops Off." Taking the very worst of the Q1 numbers we discussed a while back, the article literally asks: "Has the green bubble burst?" And paints a picture of cleantech funding drying up in the aftermath of a "hype cycle" and entrepreneurs being left out to dry.
Huh?
As we've discussed, the quarterly numbers are significantly down, but at a rate pretty comparable to what happened to venture capital overall. The whole economy came to a crashing halt, after all. It's not easy times for entrepreneurs, but it's not like there aren't deals being done (in fact, see below).
And what bubble in the first place? Was there a solar bubble? Most probably -- as we've talked about here for a while now, the solar sector got frothy in 2007-2008, as the quotes in the article reflect. Was there a corn-based ethanol bubble? Definitely.
But to simply declare that there was a "green bubble", as if solar and biofuels made up the entirety of the investment opportunities in the sector? I don't know any investors arguing that sectors like water, energy efficiency, agriculture, etc. are over-capitalized. At least not yet (stay tuned). And smart investors have always had a broad view of what "cleantech" (or whatever phrase they prefer) means. So a bit of unnecessarily breathless reporting.
But what else would we expect from an industry with such a dim future as print newspapers?
So let's take the opportunity to mention all the deals from the past few weeks:
Rob Day is a Boston-based cleantech venture capital investor and entrepreneur, and is also the President of the Renewable Energy Business Network (REBN). The views expressed on this blog are those of Rob and his friends and colleagues, not necessarily the views of REBN or Greentech Media or any other group. Contact Rob Day at: (JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)
Comments [1]