A couple of months back we discussed the potential impacts on cleantech venture capital from a possible recession.
Since then that "possible" recession now seems to be hitting in full force, with a lot of pessimism out there at the highest (well, not the VERY highest) levels.
So does that mean the picture's gotten clearer for those in cleantech venture capital? Nope. If anything, opinions are even more widely cast at this point, showing that no one really knows anything.
In the past few days, we've seen arguments all over the map. Here's a column which argues that green technology could be recession-proof. Then there's consultant Rob Enderle, whom I heard this morning on NPR, arguing that green technology could be the hardest hit of all tech sectors because green techs are "feel-good" only, with poor economics. Finally, Eric Janszen hopes that cleantech could be the "good bubble" that floats the rest of the economy through the coming rough times...
We still don't know how it will turn out. For yours truly, it's still looking "third scenario" out there in the industry, at least so far. In 2008, it looks likely that exits will be harder to come by, and that'll have a negative impact on some existing portfolios (esp. those with big cash burn), as well as a dampening impact on all the generalists still on the fence about whether to jump in or not. And while debt markets sort themselves out, project financing could be harder to come by. But the dealflow remains healthy, cleantech VCs so far remain active, large corporations are still very eager to get into the market, and for clean technologies that DO have strong economic value propositions (Mr. Enderle's learned opinion notwithstanding), customers seem very eager to capture cost savings. So, we'll stick by the "third scenario" (2008: down but not disaster) forecast... at least for now.
Speaking of cleantech venture activity not slowing down, here are deals from the last few days:
Environmental Operating Solutions, which has technology for the removal of nitrogen from wastewater, has raised a $2.5mm Series A, led by Stuart Mill Venture Partners. The company had previously been backed by angels.
CleanFish, a distributor of sustainably-harvested seafood, raised a Series A (VWire reports it at $4.2mm) led by TBL Capital, and including Mindful Capital and individual investors.
Cleantech investors in the news: A cleantech hedge fund gets launched... Speaking of TBL Capital, Clean Technology Investor reports that they now have six portfolio companies in their $50mm fund... And VentureWire reports that Masdar will no longer make any LP investments in cleantech venture capital firms, instead they're going to focus on direct investments.
Rob Day is a Partner with Black Coral Capital, based in Boston. He has been a cleantech private equity investor since 2004, and acts or has served as a Director, Observer and advisory board member to multiple companies in the energy tech and related sectors. Rob was a co-founder of the Renewable Energy Business Network (www.rebn.org), a non-profit organization which was acquired in 2009 by the Clean Economy Network. The views expressed on this blog are those of Rob, not necessarily the views of any of his colleagues and affiliated organizations. Contact Rob at .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address).
contact rob at .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)