• Friday, November 20, 2009 Latest Update: 4:41PM
Rob Day | November 6, 2009 at 10:00 AM 3 Comments

Friday follies

Some random links and observations on a Friday:

  • Apparently not every reader picked up on the fact that my last post was tongue-in-cheek.  Guess you had to be there.  Fortunately, Scott was in fact there...
  • David Gold wrote recently on some of the same issues, wondering why solar and the like have gotten so much attention from VCs while technologies like geothermal have gotten much less attention.  His answer is that in large part "much of the bias has to do with the fact that not many VCs have strong networks of geologists, drilling technologists, heat pump engineers and steam turbine power generation experts to build great geothermal companies".  I'm directionally in alignment with David's take -- obviously I agree that VCs need to broaden their horizons into other sectors of cleantech, and acknowledge it's easier said than done when it requires learning new markets, new technologies, etc.  However, I'm not sure geothermal is the best example for this.  VCs going into solar and biofuels are following the few available examples of good exits in the sector, geothermal plays are often challenged in VC eyes in terms of their capital intensity and lack of opportunities for new intellectual property, and it's not yet a fast-adopting market.  Same challenges for VCs looking into other sectors like ocean power, grid-scale storage, etc.  Like it or not, not all attractive market opportunities are a good fit for the venture capital model.

 

Comments [3]

  • z2010m 11/11/09 4:24 AM

    You wrote; “Like it or not, not all attractive market opportunities are a good fit for the venture capital model.” Could the tax code be incentivised for targeted (very specific) sectors with longer devekopment time? Allowing VC’s to get the right eixt multiple, while building national capacity and technology for long term, stable, renewable electricity (such as geothermal and ocean power). Short term loss of tax revenue would be offset by the long term reduction of trade deficit by lowering oil imports. Read elsewhere that the grid will be challenged with all the new electric and plug in hybrid vehicles requiring charging in the near future.

    Reply
      • Rob 11/13/09 9:07 AM

        Absolutely there could a number of ways to try to address the gap with policies and incentives, great thought.

  • rooferguy 11/12/09 8:03 PM

    The key challenges are that geothermal has higher and more variable costs, much more complexity, less reliability and less scalability than solar.

    You can put a solar panels on any sunny roof in less than a day and generate a lot of electricity.

    You never know when you drill a well how much it will cost and how much energy you can extract.

    Hence more VC interest in solar.

    Reply

Cleantech Investing

Rob Day is a Boston-based cleantech venture capital investor and entrepreneur, and is also the President of the Renewable Energy Business Network (REBN). The views expressed on this blog are those of Rob and his friends and colleagues, not necessarily the views of REBN or Greentech Media or any other group. Contact Rob Day at: (JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)

.